The Best Caffeine Eye Creams in 2023: SkinCeuticals, Dermalogica, More

Every product on this page was chosen by a Harper's BAZAAR editor. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.

Featuring expert picks from SkinCeuticals, Dermalogica, and more.

Even if you're not a coffee person, you can probably still appreciate the special power of caffeine. And when it comes to your skincare routine? The best caffeine eye creams feature the same main ingredient as a cup of Joe, but since your under-eyes don't need a recharge, these products aim to reduce inflammation and fine lines instead.

"As a powerful antioxidant, anti-inflammatory and vasoconstrictor, caffeine has numerous skin benefits for the under-eye area," Blair Murphy-Rose, board-certified dermatologist at the Laser and Skin Surgery Center of New York, tells Bazaar. In addition to reducing puffiness and discoloration, caffeine eye creams can also boost collagen production, which ultimately helps treat fine lines and combat free radical damage. "By targeting several under-eye concerns all at once, caffeine is a coveted ingredient in an eye cream," she adds.

Those with sensitive skin can still reap the benefits of one of the best caffeine eye creams. Murphy-Rose says to look for formulas that are hypoallergenic, as well as free of fragrance, parabens, and dyes.

To help round out your regimen, we've pulled together a short list of eye cream favorites professionals and beauty lovers agree deserve top marks.

Related: The Best Under-Eye Patches to Minimize Puffiness, Dryness, and More

"This is an excellent all-around retinol-free eye cream that contains caffeine plus a unique combination of peptides and flavonoids to firm, tone and youthen skin," Murphy-Rose says of SkinCeuticals' A.G.E. Eye Complex. "Optical diffusers minimize the appearance of dark circles. Proxylane and blueberry extract support and fortify the skin matrix and restore water to dehydrated under eye skin to plump and diminish fine lines."

This top-rated under-eye cream from The Inkey List is a steal at under $15. It combines caffeine with albizia julibrissin bark extract and a specialty peptide blend to smooth and reduce puffiness.

One satisfied customer writes: "Best eye cream I’ve used. So hydrating and smooth, a little goes a long way so the tube will last a long time too! Great product for such a low price." —Beth

Here's a cream that specifically targets blue and brown dark circles, making it a breeze to brighten your under-eyes. It combines phe-resorcinol with caffeine and La Roche-Posay's coveted thermal water to illuminate without irritation.

One satisfied customer writes: "Let’s face it, things are stressful right now and dark eye circles are a norm. I decided to try this eye cream and I’m glad that I did. It’s not a concealer. It magically diminishes the appearance of dark circle and is a good base for my make up. I highly recommend it." —JLK

"Green tea is another great antioxidant and anti-inflammatory ingredient to look for, which also contains some caffeine," Murphy-Rose notes. This option from K-beauty brand TonyMoly has a lightweight formula that quickly absorbs into the skin.

One satisfied customer writes: "I first tried TonyMoly The Chok Chok face cream a few years ago and when I needed an eye cream for my puffy under-eyes and saw this in my search results, I knew I needed to look no further. This formula is lightweight and easily absorbs, and is not heavily scented. It relieves my eye puffiness and moisturizes the sensitive skin around them. I would recommend this to anyone looking for a lightweight eye cream." —Stephanie

We awarded Ilia's Bright Start Retinol Alternative Eye Cream with a 2023 Bazaar Skincare Award for good reason: It's a favorite among editors (myself included) for reducing puffiness and fine lines, and provides the perfect pre-concealer skin prep.

One satisfied customer writes: "This is the best eye cream. I am obsessed with the cooling massage top for blending it in. I already see a difference in reducing under eye puffiness. It’s a must-have for me now!" —Lauren B.

Herbivore Botanicals's Super Nova eye cream works to brighten dark under-eye circles in seven days flat, using tumeric and potent THD vitamin C. It's best used in your daily routine, especially since it also makes a great primer.

One satisfied customer writes: "This is the best eye cream! Really helps to brighten my under eyes and is a must use every morning." —Brittney P.

100% Pure's Coffee Bean Caffeine Eye Cream sources its main ingredient from both coffee and green tea, making it extra concentrated. Its formula also nicely includes rosehip oil to keep skin supple and nourished.

One satisfied customer writes: "This has been one of my favorite staple products for so many years. I can’t ever be without it! Love the smell so much and the tightening effect, it’s amazing how quickly you see firming results. I also love the glowy bright affect it gives while wearing. My favorite thing to use on the go traveling or when my under eyes look puffy with bags. One of the few products I will consistently always repurchase, thank you!!!" —Amanda

You only need to use a small amount of Mario Badescu's Caffeine Eye Cream each day to seamlessly reduce puffiness and wrinkles. As a bonus, it also contains squalane and jojoba oil to keep dry under-eyes moisturized.

One satisfied customer writes: "Was hesitant to try this because the price is pretty low compared to some eye creams I've used. But I also wasn't finding one that brightened my dark circles. I figured I had nothing to lose! Wow! Was I surprised! I noticed a difference by the 3rd night. I plan on rebuying when I run out but the jar is quite a good size and only a little is needed. So I'll be good for awhile!" —Hayden S.

Murphy-Rose also suggests this eye gel from Dermalogica, which uses caffeine and active peptides to minimize congestion, plump fine lines, and brighten under-eyes.

One satisfied customer writes: "Love the gel opposed to cream around the eyes. Gives a baby soft feel, glides on effortlessly and de-puffs. Does just as described." —Michelle

Unlike other creams, you can use this one around your entire eye contour without worrying about irritation. And not only does its caffeine, kakudu plum extract, and peptide formula firm skin, it also aims to improve crepey lids and upper eyelid sagging.

One satisfied customer writes: "I have always had extra skin on my eyelids, both bottom and top. It didn't really age me much but it was bothersome. Especially when applying eyeliner. I used under 1 eye the first night and OMG could you tell a difference! This has tightened my skin more than I even expected was possible, minus plastic surgery. This is now a permanent in my skincare routine and I will be devastated to the point of suing for mental distress if they ever discontinue it!" —JLEW42

The name of this popular cream says it all: Featuring ingredients like hydrating shea butter, wrinkle-smoothing peptides, plus, coleus forskohlii extract to de-puff, a little goes a long when it comes to this skin essential.

One satisfied customer writes: "This eye cream makes such a difference to my under eyes. It really helps to plump the skin and reduce any fine lines from causing my make up to sit in them during the day. It doesn't irritate my eyes which during hay-fever time is always a worry." —Vics26

This vegan option is nicely safe for contact wearers. It contains niacinamide, hyaluronic acid, THD vitamin C, and of course, caffeine, that directly target hyperpigmentation while improving texture.

One satisfied customer writes: "Dark circles who? The way that this cream instantly made my dark circles disappear is amazing! I also love that there is a cooling tip because it helps with the puffiness I have in the mornings. My under-eyes also felt hydrated throughout the day which is something I normally don't have due to dryness. I look forward to seeing how this changes my under-eyes over the next few weeks!" —Krissy D.

If you're a fan of Caudalie's Vinoperfect Dark Spot Serum, this cream from the brand should fit nicely into your product rotation. It has a cooling ceramic tip that helps de-puff while evening the texture of your eye contour.

"Caffeine eye creams can be applied once or twice per day, or just at night depending on other ingredients in its formulation," Murphy-Rose explains. "For example, retinol should only be used once a day under the eyes before bedtime."

Caffeine is a go-to among skin experts, and one of the best and most effective ingredients to target under-eye puffiness. Other top ingredients also include arnica and vitamin K.

According to Murphy-Rose, signs of irritation include redness, itching, burning, swelling, peeling, roughness, and watery eyes. "Be aware that contact hypersensitivity reactions are delayed, so symptoms may develop five to seven days after exposure to an offending product," she advises.

For more than 150 years, Harper’s Bazaar has been the preeminent fashion and beauty resource for women at every age. We cover what’s new and what’s next in beauty by working with the world’s leading authorities in dermatology, plastic surgery, cosmetics, skincare, haircare, and fragrance. Every story we publish has been thoroughly researched and vetted by our team of beauty editors and industry experts.

Tiffany Dodson is currently the associate beauty commerce editor at Harper’s Bazaar, where she specializes in trend forecasting, building relationships with major and emerging brands, and crafting shopping stories—from holiday gift guides to product road tests. Tiffany's work has previously been featured in outlets like SELF, Bustle, and Teen Vogue, and she's been quoted as a commerce and beauty expert in publications and platforms like The Business of Fashion and NPR’s Life Kit podcast.

The 20 Best Hair Tools for Every Styling Need

Rihanna’s Fenty Perfume Is Now a Body Cream

The Lancôme x Louvre Collab Is Here

The 12 Best Nail Polish Top Coats

The Best Nude Nail Polishes for Every Skin Tone

Shop These 12 Shampoos for Shiny Gray Hair

The 11 Best Pedicure Colors of 2023

Get Rid of Pool Hair with These Essential Shampoos

11 Microcurrent Devices to Sculpt Your Face, Fast

The Best LED Masks for Wrinkles, Acne, and More

Here’s Exactly How Experts Get Rid of Facial Hair

9 Plush Meditation Cushions Experts Love